The Attorney’s Guide to Working with Forensic Experts: Process, Pitfalls, and Best Practices

Attorneys across Austin and Central Texas regularly rely on forensic psychologists for evaluations, risk assessments, and expert testimony. Yet, many legal professionals find the process unclear or encounter pitfalls that delay cases or weaken their arguments. As a forensic psychology practitioner with 14+ years of experience serving both prosecution and defense, I’ve seen firsthand how collaboration between attorneys and experts can make or break a case.

This guide is designed to demystify the process, highlight common mistakes, and share best practices so you get the most out of your forensic referrals.

Understanding the Process: What Attorneys Can Expect

1. Clear Referral Questions Are Key

The quality of a forensic evaluation starts with the referral. Be specific about what you need answered (e.g., competency, risk of re-offending, mitigation for sentencing, parental fitness).

2. Collaboration from Day One

Early communication helps ensure the evaluation is tailored to your legal questions and timelines. I offer a brief consult to clarify scope and expectations before the assessment begins.

3. Evidence-Based Assessment

Forensic evaluations involve clinical interviews, psychometric testing (MMPI, MCMI, PAI, IQ/achievement), and collateral review. My approach is direct, reality-based, and always aligned with court standards.

4. Timely, Court-Ready Reports

Attorneys need reliable timelines. My standard is a three-week turnaround from referral to report delivery, with clear, defensible findings and recommendations.

5. Expert Testimony and Support

I am available for depositions, pre-trial conferences, and courtroom testimony as needed. My goal: clear, concise, and impartial communication that stands up to scrutiny.

Common Pitfalls (and How to Avoid Them)

Pitfall 1: Vague or Broad Referral Questions

Solution: Specify exactly what you need. For example: “Is the defendant competent to stand trial?” or “What is the risk of recidivism given the current circumstances?”

Pitfall 2: Delayed or Incomplete Records

Solution: Provide all relevant records and background materials up front. Missing information can delay the process and limit the value of the evaluation.

Pitfall 3: Unrealistic Timelines

Solution: Plan ahead when possible. While I offer expedited services when needed, comprehensive evaluations require time for accuracy and thoroughness.

Pitfall 4: Not Involving the Expert Early Enough

Solution: Consult with your expert at the outset of the case, especially if you anticipate needing testimony or specialized assessments.

Best Practices for Attorneys

• Communicate Early and Clearly: Outline your legal questions, deadlines, and expectations.

• Provide Complete Documentation: Police reports, medical records, prior evaluations, and any other potentially relevant information.

• Ask About Methodology: Understand what tools and standards your expert uses. This will help you prepare for cross-examination.

• Request Sample Reports: Reviewing a redacted sample can help you anticipate format and depth.

• Clarify Fees and Timelines Upfront: Transparency avoids misunderstandings and keeps your case on track.

• Build a Relationship: Having a go-to forensic expert can streamline future cases and improve outcomes for your clients.

Why Work with Dr. Tedder?

• 14+ years’ experience with criminal, family, and civil cases

• Court-ready, defensible reports delivered in three weeks

• Experience with both prosecution and defense

• Direct, reality-based approach rooted in Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT)

• Convenient North Austin location and remote consultation options

Forensic experts can be powerful allies in the courtroom when attorneys know how to collaborate effectively. By clarifying questions, providing documentation, and involving your expert early, you’ll get the best results for your clients.

Have a case in mind or want to learn more about the process? Visit my dedicated page for attorneys and legal professionals or contact me directly to discuss your needs.